News 
 National News 
 National 
 General 
 Art or Porn: debate continues over those photos 

Art or Porn: debate continues over those photos

26/05/2008 10:19:00 AM
ARCHITECT Zahava Elenberg was 12 when she posed for controversial artist Bill Henson. Now, more than 20 years later, she has "absolutely no regrets".

Ms Elenberg, now a 34-year-old mother, and another woman who once posed for Henson's dark and evocative photographs, yesterday came forward to offer a spirited defence of the artist, whose works were seized in Sydney last week.

"Bill asked my mother at an exhibition opening if I would like to pose for him and we talked about it and decided to do it," Ms Elenberg, who did not pose nude, said.

"We went to this old building in Melbourne. It was quite dark, but I never felt uncomfortable. Bill made you feel incredibly safe and calm. I never felt that I wasn't in control."

National Gallery of Victoria chairman Allan Myers yesterday also came to Henson's defence, saying the furore over the internationally acclaimed artist's images depicting naked children reflected Australia's intolerance of artistic expression.

"I just think it reflects the general immaturity of our society that the coppers go blundering into an art gallery and start grabbing what are indubitably works of art on the grounds that someone has been 'disgusted'," said Mr Myers, a leading lawyer and art collector.

Mr Myers, who stressed he was speaking in a personal capacity, said the right of people including the Prime Minister and Opposition Leader to be disturbed by Henson's work had nothing to do with what should determine rules of freedom of expression.

"But I don't think Australia has been very tolerant of artistic expression — ever. I don't think things have got worse, they are still bad," he said.

The issue of whether the Melbourne-based artist's depictions of children and youth are "art" or "porn" has polarised the community since Sydney police seized 20 of Henson's images, featuring a naked girl and boy said to be aged 12 and 13. Charges are being considered.

Another mother, Joelle Baudet, who posed naked for Henson as a 24-year-old, said she was approached by the photographer at a gallery opening in the mid-1990s.

"The experience was enlightening … His work is sublime and only a warped mind could associate it with such crassness. My children and I enjoy seeing his photographs daily in our home."

Child advocates insist the images sexualise children and say no one could "consent" to them. Retired family court judge John Fogarty said the images he had seen were "shocking", while the chief executive of the Child Wise group, Bernadette McMenamin, said she was concerned about how "consent" had been obtained.

"It is clear from the UN convention on the rights of the child that parents do not have the right to make that decision on behalf of their children," Ms McMenamin said.

Hetty Johnson, of the group Bravehearts, who appears to have lodged the complaint that resulted in the police raid, said the community outrage was "a message to the arts world to be responsible, not to be selfish around this".

Federal Families Minister Jenny Macklin said she disagreed with the photographs, but she also did not agree with "the way in which children are being bombarded in many other places".

Send to a Friend
Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size



Comments


I have to say that naked children are natural , overly dressed children are not. We should be able to enjoy natures gifts in art.
Posted by Robbie on 26/05/2008 11:54:15 AM
The ALP is shooting itself in the foot on this. I've seen the photo of Zahava when she was 12 and agree with her. It's beautiful. This sort of "outrage" will backfire.
Posted by stupid alp on 29/05/2008 7:56:13 PM
I went to school with Zahava. The time that the portrait was done, we would have been at school together. She was always very bright for her age and quite outspoken. If she was not comfortable with something she would have said so. I knew her for 3yrs+. She hasn't changed much since I last saw her. Amazing! I wouldn't let my kids pose, but that's my opinion.
Posted by Nee FitzSimons on 14/08/2008 9:21:39 AM
1

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
ARCHITECT Zahava Elenberg was 12 when she posed for controversial artist Bill Henson. Now, more than 20 years later, she has absolutely no regrets. Photo: Wayne Taylor
ARCHITECT Zahava Elenberg was 12 when she posed for controversial artist Bill Henson. Now, more than 20 years later, she has "absolutely no regrets". Photo: Wayne Taylor

13/08/2008 | Catherine Deveny is no fan of sport. So why is she parked in front of the TV, with bowl of chicken soup in hand?
100 Years of Scouting